Chalkbeat's journalism is made possible by our sponsors.
Interested in becoming one? Reach out here.
Hello from the national desk — it’s Lily.
I got a taste of an old-fashioned recess this month, when I visited a school in northern Michigan. Kids were climbing a massive, frozen mound of snow as if it were a tower. They screeched into the sky. Today’s big story is about this school — and why the district banned screens for its youngest students in the middle of the year.
We also look at how a bad week in court for Meta could be bellwether for school districts suing social media companies, research into the practice of red-shirting kindergartners, and the unlikely comeback of cursive.
The Big Story

Students pick out books from the book-vending machine at Mesick Consolidated Schools. The school has recently banned screens hoping to improve literacy scores. (Kristen Norman for Chalkbeat)
I visited Mesick, Michigan last week, a small, rural town in the northern half of the state, to see what it looks like when a school district makes a drastic pivot in the middle of the school year.
In Mesick’s case, a meeting between the elementary school principal and superintendent led to an all-out ban of devices in the elementary school. Not just phones, but school-issued Chromebooks and tablets.
The backdrop here is a fierce and swift backlash against technology in classrooms, that’s been building for a while now, championed by a pretty wide swath of folks like Jonathan Haidt, some teachers unions, and lawmakers from both sides of the aisle who are introducing bills to limit ed-tech in the classroom.
Mesick Superintendent Jack Ledford told me he’s been influenced by Haidt, as well as research he’s seen that makes him worry that screens are doing more harm than good in the fight to teach students to read.
Some students and educators were surprised — and maybe a little panicked — when Ledford and Principal Elizabeth Kastl announced their no-screen rule. But a month into the experiment, teachers and most students said they are doing pretty well without their Chromebooks (which they’ll still use for state testing this spring) and tablets.
“We're going to create people who can think and read and respond and talk to others and have social interactions and not just be glued to a screen,” Kastl said.
More National News
Red-shirting is not actually on the rise, and it doesn’t help students much. According to a new analysis from the testing organization NWEA, the practice of having students start kindergarten late peaked during the pandemic and now is back to historical levels. Older students who started school during the 2021-22 school year did do better than their younger classmates at first, but the advantage wore off by third grade.
Local Stories to Watch

Muslim students in the Detroit Public Schools Community District are frustrated they can't get the $100 perfect attendance incentive if they missed school to observe Eid al-Fitr. (Sylvia Jarrus for Chalkbeat )
New York City’s education department released a long-awaited AI policy, but districts have already formed policies of their own. In the absence of a districtwide policy, schools in New York have tackled the use of artificial intelligence apps like ChatGPT for schoolwork. Preliminary guidelines released Tuesday include an early framework outlining approved uses and uses that would require educator oversight.
Muslim students in Detroit say a school policy that pays students for perfect attendance is unfair. If students want to miss school to observe religious holidays often not included in the school calendar — like the sacred Muslim holiday Eid al-Fitr — they miss out on the cash incentive, because observance isn’t considered an excused absence.
Tennessee Republicans advanced a bill that would relax state testing requirements for schools in one of the state’s two voucher programs. Private schools that participate in the Education Scholarships Accounts could have the option to administer a “nationally standardized achievement test” to students instead of the state’s assessment. The bill comes months after a state audit found that while overall testing outcomes are improving, students receiving ESA money largely performed worse on Tennessee’s state assessment than public school students.
Six Colorado nonprofits have formed a statewide youth coalition with the goal of empowering people ages 16 through 34. Leaders of the new coalition say they hope it will drive conversations about important issues among young people. The coalition also plans to put young adults in the driver’s seat for a June gubernatorial forum.
Spotlight on …
successful (so far) lawsuits against a social media giant
It’s been a losing week in courtrooms across the West for Meta, the company behind Instagram and Facebook. The legal momentum may suggest what’s to come for school districts challenging the social media giants.
In Los Angeles today, a court found Instagram and YouTube liable for a 20-year-old woman’s addiction to social media, harming her mental health. The verdict awards her with $3 million in damages in what many have called a landmark case.
And on Tuesday in New Mexico, Meta was ordered to pay $375 million after a jury in New Mexico found the company violated state law, and failed to protect children from sexual exploitation. Meta has plans to challenge the verdict, said a company spokesperson.
Dozens of school districts have filed similar lawsuits against Meta, claiming its platforms were designed to ensnare children into social media addiction, harming the students districts serve. Arguments for the consolidated suits could begin this summer.
Districts have argued that they are on the hook for societal ills they didn’t create — but that social media companies like Meta did.
“For school districts in particular, they are saying that now they have to redirect resources that could otherwise be used on teaching and the curriculum to manage these mental health issues that are caused by excessive usage of these social media platforms,” Princess Uchekwe, an attorney in New York, told EdSurge earlier this year.
Did You Know?
11,000
That’s how many U.S. citizen children saw at least one parent deported in the first seven months of President Donald Trump’s second term, according to a data analysis by ProPublica. The real number might be higher. Mothers were four times as likely to be deported during that time period as they were during Joe Biden’s administration.
In some cases, parents ended up in deportation proceedings after a school called the police about problems between children that never resulted in any criminal charges.
Quote of the Week
“I'm like, ‘Are you kidding me, cursive club, what do I need that for?’”
That’s 11-year-old Antonio Benavides, an initially skeptical member of a cursive club at a Virginia middle school. With more than two dozen states requiring cursive instruction, there’s reason to believe the writing method is making a comeback.
Looking for your next read? Check out these other great newsletters.



